The Rise and Fall of Secularism in Modern Turkey

By  Yasir M’alik.

Secularism has been a dominant belief system in the republic of Turkey since 1928, the times when it was constitutionally recognized and enforced under the patronage of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk (the founder of the Republic). Within the first three decades, state-driven secular reforms were introduced to reverse the remnants of the Ottomanism to intentionally alter the whole framework of the society on Westernized liberal thought. Ataturk initiated, in this context, a series of social, political, legal and economic reforms (in the name of Kemalism) to secularize the prevalent order of the society, banned sharia courts, closed all madrasas, shut down private Islamic orders and banished religious education from state schools.

Most strikingly, Ataturk abolished the caliphate – (the office of political and religious leader of the Muslim faith that Ottoman Sultans had claimed since the 15th century). Aiming to remould the everyday habits of Turks, traditional Islamic forms of headdress such as turbans and the fez were banned and the hijab was outlawed in public offices. The Turkish military served as the nation’s firewall, backing and guarding the aspirations and secular reforms of its founder, Mustafa Kemal Ataturk. Till the emergence of the multi-party system in Turkey in 1946, it was unchallenged. Yet despite massive reforms, secularism (Kemalism) barely infiltrated Turkish society at large. The rural and pious masses of the republic remained largely unaffected by the cultural re engineering of Ataturk.


Recep Tayyip Erdogan-led AKP’s political journey remained highly successful since its coming to power in 2002, when it gained absolute majority in 2002 elections.


The elections 1946 and the victory of Democrats, often dubbed as pro-Islamists, gave a slight blow to the Secular patrons although this victory was not inspired by the public desire for an Islamic regime. However, constitutionally established and militarily protected, secularism maintained its hegemony on power till the late 1970s. Decades after decades, Secularism that had, once, become a prevalent fashion in the Turkish society, came under threat due to the persistently disappointing governing performance of the secular and pro-secular military regimes. This gave some space to rise the pro-Islamic political parties in the late 1970s. The rise of pro-Islamic political parties came under intermittent civilian and military crackdowns owing to their gradually rising recognition and somewhat popularity among the public. Many of these pro-Islamic political parties were even banned periodically owing to their violations to disrespect country’s strict secular principles.  

ALSO READ: Political Islam & Growing Influence of Tayyab Erdogan

In 1995, Turkish public brought Necmettin Erbakan (a leading Islamist figure in the modern-Turkish history who was previously banned from entering politics) led political party into power. Erbakan became Prime Minister and he sluggishly started to ease some restrictions over the Islamic identity, imposed constitutionally under the military rule. The military (powerful guardian of secularism), once again, repeated its interventionist agenda, but indirectly this time due to its notorious popularity of past records and thrown Erbakan from power in 1997. The consecutive military’s involvement in politics and crackdown of the pro-Islamic regimes spurred serious soul-searching among Turkey’s Islamists.


The ruling AKP, in tandem with many socio-economic developments, remarkably substituted the secular fabric of the society by transforming it largely into an Islamic-oriented architecture.


Eventually, Islamists, seeking lessons from the past, learned to take a different path and started their journey under the Justice and Development Party (AKP), a faction of predecessor pro-Islamic political parties, who initially portrayed them as ‘Conservatives’ and ‘Western-oriented Moderates’. Recep Tayyip Erdogan-led AKP’s political journey remained highly successful since its coming to power in 2002, when it gained absolute majority in 2002 elections (which was for the 1st time in modern Turkish history by a political party). To earn the support of the opponent sections of the society and to extend its power base, the AKP initially followed Ataturk’s vision of governance and remain focused to comply with EU membership guidelines. The AKP by dint of its economic successes regained its political majority in the 2007 elections and this time with a massive increased votes. During the second tenure of its rule, the AKP embarked on its overt agenda of reversing the secular restrictions with modernized and flamboyant Islamic-oriented patterns (often named as neo-Ottomanism), backing with the procurement of broader public trust. Later, in the coming years, the AKP maintained its successful political journey in the 2011 Grand National Assembly elections, 2014 Presidential elections and again in, 2015 Turkish Grand National Assembly elections notwithstanding many obstructions and challenges.

For almost one and half decade in power, the AKP  boosted up country’s economic graph by bringing Turkey into the list of G-20 major economies along with projecting massive social, political and constitutional reforms. Besides all, today under the AKP, Turkey is ranked 1st in terms of hosting Refugees, 2nd in humanitarian aid, 6th in World Tourism, 8th in military strength and 17th in terms of largest nominal GDP.  The ruling AKP, in tandem with many socio-economic developments, remarkably substituted the secular fabric of the society by transforming it largely into an Islamic-oriented architecture.

ALSO READ: Turkey: Erdoganism, Attempted Coups and the Way Forward

Once predominant secularism is now under threat by the growing popularity of pro-Islamic version of the Turkish society. Even after the exposition of the AKP’s pro-Islamic agenda, almost 52% of the general public supports the pro-Islamic policies of the ruling AKP. Utilizing the gambits of its economic successes and broader public support, the AKP is on the roads of Islamizing the whole fabric of the Turkish society. With almost 15 years on the driving seat, it has conducted massive alterations ranging from the educational curriculum to institutions by appointing and promoting pro-Islamic mindset to public offices and also with the majority public opinion. The AKP has tried to infuse Islamic or at least pro-Islamic attitudes in the state machinery and policy-making institutions.

There are many reservations and accusations, Seculars associate with the AKP, that it has and continues to impose its Islamic agenda over the Turkish society and all of its elements against the public will, defying its secular foundations. However, the research indicators reveals that three consecutive massive victories advocate the legitimacy of the AKP and its pro-Islamic policies. Besides, more than 50% votes in the parliamentary forum and also in the plebiscite of constitutional amendments is a logic of its legitimacy for pro-Islamic engineering of the society at the expense of secular adaptation.

About Author:

The writer is a research fellow at South Asian Strategic Stability Institute, Islamabad. Areas of expertise include Afghanistan and Turkey.

He can be reached at yasirturk800@gmail.com.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *